collection of diverse antique earrings

Earrings trends

a beginner's guide to collecting antique earrings

By Eleanor Ainsworth

Published: 20 May 2025

“Jewelry is like ice cream. There's always room for more.”

A Beginner's Guide to Collecting Antique Earrings

Okay, let’s be real. Shiny things are just… irresistible. And when those shiny things come with a story, a history, maybe a little bit of mystery? Well, sign me up! Antique earrings aren't just accessories; they are wearable history. My grandma used to say, ‘Every piece tells a story, you just need to listen.’ I never really understood what she meant until I held a pair of Victorian jet earrings, imagining the woman who wore them during a time of mourning. Creepy? Maybe. Captivating? Absolutely!

This guide? It’s for anyone who's ever been captivated by the sparkle of something old. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just starting, let’s dive in! Ever wonder where do you even begin with collecting antique earrings? Well, buckle up, buttercup. We're about to find out!

Victorian woman wearing jet earrings

Victorian woman wearing jet earrings | Image: Supplied

Why Collect Antique Earrings?

Beyond the sheer beauty and historical significance, collecting antique earrings is a uniquely personal journey. It's like curating a miniature art gallery for your ears! Each pair whispers tales of bygone eras, reflecting the fashion, artistry, and even the societal norms of their time. Plus, let's be honest, antique jewelry is just plain cool and makes you feel like you know a secret no one else does. Why buy something everyone else has when you can sport something unique?

  • A tangible connection to history: Earrings worn by someone from another era? How cool is that?! It’s like time-traveling, but with your ears.
  • Investment potential: Valuable antique earrings can appreciate over time, making them a sound financial investment. Though, I wouldn't think too much about the investment part and collect earrings that simply speaks to you. The value will come later!
  • Uniqueness and individuality: In a world of mass-produced fashion, antique earrings offer a chance to express your unique style. Plus, they make great conversation starters at parties! One of my friends once wore a pair of Edwardian earrings to a gallery opening, and she was instantly the star of the show! Everyone asked about them.
antique earrings displayed in a museum

antique earrings displayed in a museum | Image: Supplied

Identifying Antique Earrings: What to Look For

So, you're ready to start your collection. Great! But how do you tell a genuine antique from a cleverly disguised replica? Don't worry; you don't need to be a jewelry expert. Here are some key things to keep in mind:

  • Hallmarks and Maker's Marks: These are tiny stamps that indicate the metal content (like 925 for sterling silver) or the maker of the piece. Grab a magnifying glass and search for these marks on the earring posts, backs, or ear wires. A missing hallmark doesn't always mean it's not antique, but it's definitely something to consider. I once found a pair of beautiful Art Deco earrings at a flea market, but the missing hallmark made me suspicious. Turns out, they were a very well-made reproduction. Live and learn!
  • Materials: Common materials used in antique earrings include gold, silver, platinum, jet, and various gemstones. Familiarize yourself with the materials popular in different eras. For example, paste (high-quality glass) was frequently used in Georgian and Victorian jewelry. My great aunt, bless her heart, was convinced all her 'diamond' earrings were real. Bless.
  • Construction and Style: The way an earring is constructed can be a clue to its age. Look for features like hand-cut stones, intricate filigree work, and specific clasp types that were prevalent in certain periods. Pay attention to design motifs. Certain styles, like the flowing lines of Art Nouveau or the geometric shapes of Art Deco, are characteristic of their respective eras.
  • Condition: Antique earrings will naturally show some signs of wear. Minor scratches or slight imperfections are acceptable and can even add to the piece's charm. However, be wary of excessive damage or obvious repairs, as these can significantly impact the value.

Warning!

  • Avoid pieces that look too 'perfect' and new to be true antiques. Original antiques always show signs of wear and age.
close up of antique earring hallmarks

close up of antique earring hallmarks | Image: Supplied

Each era in jewelry history has its unique characteristics. Here's a quick rundown of some popular periods:

  • Georgian (1714-1837): Handcrafted, often featuring intricate details, and set with paste stones. Earrings of this period were worn as sets with other jewelry, forming what was know as a "parure." Often the earrings would be designed to be "girandole" style (Three pear-shaped drops suspended from a decorative top). Super fancy!
  • Victorian (1837-1901): Romantic and sentimental, with motifs like flowers, hearts, and birds. Jet was often used for mourning jewelry. Queen Victoria did love her jewelry, even in mourning! Think long dangles, and big earrings. I'd describe it as very extra!
  • Art Nouveau (1890-1910): Characterized by flowing lines, organic shapes, and nature-inspired designs. Common motifs include dragonflies, butterflies, and women with flowing hair. And so pretty! These are my personal favorite!
  • Edwardian (1901-1910): Delicate and elegant, often featuring diamonds and pearls set in platinum or white gold. The use of the "milgrain" effect was very popular. It is a technique where tiny beads of metal are added around stones or edges to create a soft and refined look.
  • Art Deco (1920s-1930s): Bold and geometric, with strong lines and contrasting colors. Think flapper girls and jazz-age glamour. Think great gatsby!

Understanding these eras will help you identify and appreciate the unique beauty of antique earrings from different periods. It's like having a cheat sheet for jewelry history!

collage of antique earrings from different eras

collage of antique earrings from different eras | Image: Supplied

Where to Find Antique Earrings

So, where do you embark on your treasure hunt? Here are some good places to start:

  • Antique Stores: These are obvious, but it can be a bit of a hit or miss. Some will be priced higher than normal. Take a friend! It makes it much more fun!
  • Estate Sales: These can be a goldmine for finding unique and affordable pieces. Estate sales often involve the sale of an entire household's belongings, so you never know what hidden treasures you might uncover. A word of caution: check the sales, especially for online listings, if the listing looks sloppy or seems "off," it probably is!
  • Flea Markets: Patience is key when browsing flea markets, but the rewards can be great. Don't be afraid to haggle and always inspect pieces carefully before purchasing. Bring a jeweler's loupe! It helps!
people browsing an antique store

people browsing an antique store | Image: Supplied

Caring for Your Antique Earrings

Once you've built your collection, it's important to take care of your treasures. Here are some tips:

  • Storage: Store your earrings in a soft pouch or jewelry box to prevent scratches. Keep them separated to avoid tangling or damage. My great grandmother always kept each pair in its own velvet-lined box, and I've continued the tradition.
  • Cleaning: Gently clean your earrings with a soft cloth. Avoid harsh chemicals or abrasive cleaners, as these can damage delicate materials. For more stubborn dirt, you can use a mild soap and water solution, but be sure to dry the earrings thoroughly afterward. Be sure to research the stones of the jewelry you are cleaning as certain cleaners or soaps can have adverse effects on the stones.
  • Professional Cleaning: For valuable or particularly delicate pieces, consider having them professionally cleaned by a jeweler who specializes in antique jewelry. They'll have the expertise and tools to clean your earrings safely and effectively. My go to is always the lovely people at Tiffany's. I've had the best experience there.

Collecting antique earrings is an adventure that is so fun and fascinating. The history, the artistry, the sheer beauty—it's all incredibly rewarding. So, go ahead, embrace the sparkle, and start building your collection today!

woman cleaning antique earrings

woman cleaning antique earrings | Image: Supplied

“Jewelry is like ice cream. There's always room for more.”

Want to join our exclusive community?

WordofMany offers general content intended solely for informational purposes. The information provided is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or financial consultation. Always seek the advice of qualified professionals regarding any medical or financial decisions.

© 2024 Word of Many. All Rights Reserved.